GemeWizard
Home|About Us|Store|Color Report Newsletter|Support|News & Events|Contact|Gemstones Colors

Gemstones Colors and Prices



         


   

      Gemewizard archive daily article








  Spinning for spinel: the long march for respect

by Menahem Sevdermish FGA D.Litt.
April 18, 2013


"A gem, in order to be a gem and valuable, has to have beauty, rarity and durability." It was the first sentence uttered by my teacher, Michael O'Donoghue, when I began my formal gemological studies.

I found his maxim to be a relatively good rule of thumb, most of the time. Over the years, I have seen some pretty ugly stones fetching high prices, and some very soft stones sneaking into that group of valuable gems, as if they were as hard as diamonds. I even know of rare, durable and beautiful stones which struggle to be recognized as gems.

Which brings me to the subject of spinel. I don't know why, but in the early days, like most gem dealers I never thought much of them. Perhaps it was because I always remembered the story about the beautiful "Black Prince ruby" in the Queen of England's jewels, which turned out to be a "simple red spinel."

But over the past decade, and especially after several close encounters with spinels in Mahenge, Tanzania, I have become totally enchanted by the gemstone. Their color ranges from magnificent reds to deep pinks, to padparadcha hues, and violets and mauves and blues. Most are as rare and as beautiful as the thousands of fancy sapphires that I have cut in my career and some were far nicer and more sparkling. They are also quite hard, 8 on Mohs scale. And they have one quality that I adore - they are natural, unheated and untreated in any way.

I was sure that the whole world would see eye to eye with me. But, to my dismay, when I mentioned them, the typical response of customers would be one of discomfort. "Ah, spinel you say," they would utter warily, as if I was talking about citrine or smoky quartz, not that I mean any disrespect to these gems.

Somehow, these clients appeared to regard this very rare, hard and beautiful stone as if it were an imitation. But an imitation of what? Of rubies and sapphires that are so commonly treated the relationship between their original color and treated color is non-existent?

I couldn't understand it. Why is it that, with all the fuss we were making about treated stones, the spinel was being ignored? Here, right in front of our very eyes, was an absolutely magnificent gem in very popular colors, and it is totally natural!

And then it occurred to me. This is a case of gemstone racism. What other reason could there be for the scorn rained down upon the Black Prince ruby, which was discovered to be a rare spinel, other than some form of mineral bigotry? After all, they couldn't even bring themselves to call it the Black Prince spinel, as if in order to be worthy of a royal title you need to be a ruby.

But, even then, I believed that the future would shine brightly for spinel. After all, the only stone that my daughter agreed to wear in a necklace was a magnificent pink spinel.

For years, I found myself virtually alone in the mission to achieve some respect for this gemstone. I almost gave up, moving back to other, "more socially acceptable" precious gems.

But then, three years ago, something changed. Suddenly, the price of pink and especially red spinel gems began rising. And when I say rising, I mean the "space shuttle taking off"-kind of rising. From several hundreds of dollars per carat for a beautiful 10-carat red spinel, the prices of these gems were multiplied at least 10-fold to the area of $10,000 per carat. For bigger and rarer stones, the prices went even higher. I once heard one of my colleagues from Europe asking a whopping 20,000 euros per carat for a 15-carat red spinel.

And not only the pinks and the reds are basking in the limelight. Other spinel colors, such as violets, lilacs, lavenders, blues, have all been showing phenomenal price increases as well.

Although I had not directly influenced the sudden spin of the spinel's prices, I realized that maybe my efforts had paid off after all. We were once but a handful of spinel activists, but we had helped plant the seeds for success. It took a long time, but eventually spinel arrived at the place it deserves.

To paraphrase Michael O'Donoghue, "a gem, in order to be a gem and valuable, has to have beauty, rarity, durability," and the lobbying efforts of at least one stubborn fan.

©2007 Menahem Sevdermish, GemEwizard, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Designed by YCS - Yahalom Creative Solutions